Sunday, February 5, 2012

1,144 to win and the elephant in the room

1,144 to win

Last night, I was one of 851 singers who joined 200 instrumentalists along with one curly-haired conductor and 5,800 audience members at the Shrine Auditorium for a performance of Gustav Mahler’s Symphony Number 8. We started rehearsing on the Symphony five months ago and over the last week, had seven three-hour rehearsals at various venues across the L.A. Basin. Aside from being part of one of the largest performances of Mahler’s 8th, I spent the last three days without politics- free from television, radio and my beloved Los Angeles Times.

This morning I had a chance to read the paper and catch up on some news. Not surprising, Mitt Romney won the Nevada primary caucus, Occupy Wall Street is still chugging along, the Komen Foundation reversed its decision to withdraw funding to Planned Parenthood and the Catholic Church is up in arms over the issue of contraceptives being required as part of the new healthcare laws.

As a matter of disclosure, I’m a gay, progressive, Democrat who is in a relationship with a college professor who is a conservative, Republican, devout Catholic- yes, your head should be spinning now. That being said, I am conflicted on many levels when it comes to religion and politics, but try to be unbiased in my views and opinions. I try to look at what is best- not just for me- but what is best for all.

Arguably, everyone has an agenda. My agenda is social justice which, by default, is a very Democratic position. My partner’s Republican agenda is also [somewhat] related to social justice, as long as it doesn’t involve costing the government any money or have anything to do with funding of abortions. But how do you find a balance between social justice and conservativism?

If I profess the need for greater social welfare- by welfare I mean the common good- I get accused of being promoting an agenda that encourages people to live on the dole. If I espouse the need for health insurance for everyone, regardless of the role that government may play, I get accused of supporting Communism and Socialism. Communism and Socialism. Really?

So, this brings me to an interesting subject- the Tea Party as it relates to a New Social Movement. For all intents and purposes, it meets the criteria of a social movement, right? It has worthiness in the form of its leaders, albeit they are elected members of a specific zeitgeist. They definitely have unity: they mobilized a grass-roots movement into a massive political sub-party- which is tantamount to numbers; and they have commitment. However, I have to say that I question the movement of the Tea Party because, like OWS, I’m not sure they really know what they want.

At times, Tea Party members have staged protests with large banners that spewed visceral and reprehensible statements. By far, the most abhorrent signs accused the President of being a Nazi. Really? A mixed-race Nazi? How did the Tea Party come to represent a neo-conservative movement that operated on a platform of intolerance and hate? It appears that they were galvanized through the belief that universal healthcare was similar to socialized medicine which was the equivalent to Socialism and Communism which in turn made the President and his Administration Nazis. Simple, right? With that idea, fear supplanted any rational though and Robert’s Rules of Order was placed in a large shredder.

I had a chance to ask several people if they knew what Communism or Socialism was and threw in Fascism just for kicks. None of them knew what the definitions are, but were quick to point out the similarities to the former Soviet Block and the Obama Administration.

The social movement in the political arena can be a very dangerous thing for a candidate and when your sole objective is to get the current administration out of office- you’ll subscribe to the doctrine of who will get you there- even if that means pandering to get the vote.

My point is, that most of the contemporary social movements are questionable in at least one of the WUNC definitions- they’re just not sure what they want. And when the momentum gets going and critical mass is achieved, they implode because it just wasn’t thought through enough. The Tea Party will undoubtedly latch onto whichever candidate receives the nomination and will exhibit its unity with one thing only: get President Obama out of office and what will happen after then is anyone’s guess.

But I have to ask, what if the candidate that the Tea Party does promote vacillates on issues or decides that affordable healthcare isn’t that bad of an idea and that maybe the three branches of government aren’t all that bad? Will they the hold more protests and promote new candidates to replace the ones they put in there?

You see, I think that the C in WUNC could stand of consistency or credibility when looking at the Tea Party movement. Their credibility and consistency on issues of national importance have lacked judgment on so many levels- especially when it came to electing people to positions in which their actions can have disastrous outcomes.

However, I get it. I get the fact that they were able to bring to light some issues that needed attention is impressive and the sheer volume of people they were able to amass in a short period of time was of epic biblical proportion. But I do have to ask, will the Tea Party remain as the go-to for enlightening people who they want out of office? Or, will they remain only in the public eye during the time of an election cycle. Either way, it has been an interesting social experiment that has challenged the status quo and I’ll be curious to see what happens next.

2 comments:

Professor Dabel said...

I agree that the Tea Party seems to be conflicted in many ways. It is also interesting that they have embraced a more "mainstream" political activity: electoral politics.

P. Thomas said...

Wow Matthew! Your comments are really quite excellent. I agree that the Tea Party movement is probably going to go away once they have achieved their number one goal of getting rid of Obama and for that matter the Democratic Senate majority. Fear has worked well as the motivator of these masses. By interjecting Socialism which they equate with Communism visions of the Cold War era spring to the forefront of the minds of these 50+ seniors who make up the majority of this organization. Since the populace has a limited political science, economic and civics education, we can expect fear to continue to spark interest in these racist and socially unjust groups.